Ezine 130 – Windows Vista SP1 Review

Ezine 130 – Windows Vista SP1 ReviewMicrosoft Windows Vista SP1 Review

If you fast-forward to 2015, and then look-back; I bet that Vista’s SP1 will be hailed as a classic example of waiting until the first service pack before deploying an operating system.  Thus if you have not deployed Vista, then wait until next spring and expect a smooth migration from XP.

Windows Vista SP1 Topics

Security is still Vista’s number one priority

Let us start with a reminder of the key reason to migrate from XP to Vista, namely security.  A vulnerability study by J.R. Jones reached the conclusion that over the last six months XP had 3 times more security problems than Vista (36 issues in XP, 12 in Vista).

Ask yourself this: now that we have Vista, will hackers stop attacking XP?  I say that human nature in general, and the cowardly disposition of hackers in particular, means virus writers will always go for the weakest link = XP.  Even amongst the good guys who are fighting viruses, will they show the same determination to patch a vulnerability that affects XP, but not Vista?  I think not and thus XP will become ever more prone to maleware.

Those who are resistant to upgrading from XP to Vista should study the lessons of history.  Let us remember how fruitless the Philistines have been in destroying art, how ineffective the Luddites were at halting progress, and how stupid King Canute looked when he tried to repel the incoming tide.  Closer to home, at what point do you consider an operating system to be archaic?  Windows 3.11, Windows 98, Me,  Windows 2000, or XP.  Where would you draw the line between an acceptable operating system, and a liability?  My point is wherever you set the cut-off point today, one day XP will be on the wrong side of that line.

SP1 builds on this strong security in the following ways:

  • Vista’s SP1 provides third party anti-virus companies access to the APIs, as a result they can now work on kernel patch protection in x64-bit Vista.
  • SP1 reduces the chances of people hijacking Vista traffic, because it now allows signed sessions for Remote Desktop connections.
  • SP1 Permits multiple factor authentication for BitLocker Drive Encryption.  (I wonder how you remember them all, bearing in mind you should not write down what you did!)
  • There are more security developments such as Elliptical Curve Cryptography ECC, SSTP also SD and DMA (none of which I understand in detail).  However, at the strategic level, the message is Microsoft is still determined to make Vista secure, even if it’s at the expense of ease-of-use.

Killer role for SP1 – Patch up Vista laptops

I cannot help noticing how many of the features of Vista SP1 affect mobile computers more than desktops.

  • Many mobile devices with Vista RTM (Release to manufacturers) were slow to emerge from sleep or hibernation, these bugs have been ironed-out by Vista’s SP1.
  • Machines which join the domain, such as laptops, struggle when they have to work offline because there was no Domain Controller available.  Problem cured by SP1.  See also how Windows 8 joins a domain.
  • More methods of securing drives with BitLocker.  This has been covered earlier, but is most relevant to portable machines.
  • Secure Socket Tunnelling Protocol, SSTP.  An idea to extend VPNs across firewalls without requiring extra authentication.
  • Better reliability running external display monitors from a laptop.
  • More efficient screen refresh, specifically re-designed to improve battery life on mobile devices.
  • Support for the exFAT (Extended FAT) so loved by flash memory storage devices.

General improvements for desktops and laptops

Some printers were flaky with Vista RTM, and thankfully, SP1 has more printer drivers and also better support for Terminal Service users who print locally.

  • You can fine-tune Defrag to defragment individual drives.
  • Gamers will like the Direct3D 10.1 support.
  • Network Diagnostics – Already impressive, can now solve more file sharing problems.
  • Support for EFI (Extensible Firmware Interface).
  • Improved Java parsing for IE 7, reducing latency.
  • Removes 20 second delay when pressing Ctrl Alt Del on certain machines.

Think of Vista as version 1

The best way to understand Vista’s teething problems is not to consider it as version 6 of Windows, but as version 1 of a new line of Microsoft operating systems called: ‘Vista’!  Microsoft boast that Vista has been re-designed from scratch with security at the forefront of every decision.  To me, this means everything is new, thus version 1.  This view of Vista is the only way that I can reconcile that the original RTM version of Vista had so many errors that you just did not find in XP.  Good news, SP1 is going to fix 90% of these niggling problems, for example:

  • Windows Explorer freezes if you browse the network, even with DC (Domain Controller) present.
  • Severe latency when no DC available.
  • Machine hangs when emerging from hibernation mode.
  • 20 Second delay after pressing Ctrl +Alt +Del before the dialog box appears.


For those with Vista who never experienced the above problems, they seem trivial.  For those of us who suffered at least one of these glitches, we believed we were going mad.  I don’t want to get into Microsoft bashing but people’s natural reaction was to say, well XP did not behave in this lethargic manner.  The reason, these problems drove me mad was that I could not believe that Microsoft would ship Vista with these problems, thus it was me that was going mad.  The other reason that they are so annoying is that they are intermittent and vary from one machine to another.  We suffered even on machines that had the designed for Vista logo.

To those who enter Vista at SP1, they will be spared this frustration.

Improvements with subtle messages

Another point that caught my eye was where Microsoft say they have improved the upgrade experience from XP to Vista.  Guy translates this to mean, it was nigh impossible to upgrade XP to Vista original, and even with SP1, it may still be better to go for a fresh installation than upgrading an existing XP operation system.

On this theme of damaging admissions, SP1 improves battery life on Laptops.  Guy’s translation is: you could only run Vista RTM on Laptops connected to the mains, because the battery life was so short.  I will be looking out for reports to see if battery life on laptops with Vista SP1 equals or exceeds that of XP on the same laptop.

SP1 will uninstall GPMC, thus leaving managing Group Policy to the server.  Instead, Vista SP1 supplies GPEdit and thus focuses on the local group policies.  It’s fair to say that some people don’t think the new arrangement is an improvement.  However, it does get most network administrator’s approval because it eliminates problems caused by Psycho users who like to fiddle and destroy their desktops.

Application compatibility and logos

Look out for the better logo called: ‘Certified for Windows Vista’.  The inferior logo is called: ‘Works with Windows Vista’, this may mean that the software (or hardware) will only work if you turn off the Aero graphics.

In November 2006 only 250 applications had any type of designed for Vista logo, by August 2007 the number had risen to 2250.  The message for early Vista adopters is re-visit the site where you bought any applications and search for updates.

We all get bitten by compatibility, or to be precise, incompatibility problems.  I recently bought a video editor, the blurb said: works with XP, Windows 2000 and above, but did not work on Vista.  When this happens, it helps to know how to break out of the pass-the-buck loop.  Guy’s rule to break the blame circle is this, if the program has Certified for Vista logo, and it does not work – blame Microsoft.  If the software has no compatibility label, then blame the third party company.  In my case there was a happy ending, they gave me a full refund.

Guy Recommends: Tools4ever’s UMRAUMRA The User Management Resource Administrator

Tired of writing scripts? The User Management Resource Administrator solution by Tools4ever offers an alternative to time-consuming manual processes.

It features 100% auto provisioning, Helpdesk Delegation, Connectors to more than 130 systems/applications, Workflow Management, Self Service and many other benefits. Click on the link for more information onUMRA.

Types of SP1


Not a big Service Pack only 55 Mb, tunes the ‘package’ for each computer.


Huge 7Gb (12 Gb for x64-bit)  All versions all languages.


Volume Licensing Customers Only

As of September 2007 Vista SP1 is in beta and only available to 15,000 testers.  The final release of Vista SP1 is to be in March 2008.

Guy Recommends: The Free IP Address Tracker (IPAT) IP Tracker

Calculating IP Address ranges is a black art, which many network managers solve by creating custom Excel spreadsheets.  IPAT cracks this problem of allocating IP addresses in networks in two ways:

For Mr Organized there is a nifty subnet calculator, you enter the network address and the subnet mask, then IPAT works out the usable addresses and their ranges. 

For Mr Lazy IPAT discovers and then displays the IP addresses of existing computers. Download the Free IP Address Tracker

Will and Guy’s Humour

This week Will and Guy’s humour theme is back-to-school, we feature jokes, and short stories about teachers and pupils.

See more information about Microsoft Windows service packs

Windows 8 Tips  •E 189 Windows 7 SP1  • E 157 Vista SP2  • Windows 8 Task Manager

E 135 Vista SP1  • E 129 Vista SP1  • E 130 Vista SP1  •E 50 W2K3 SP1  • E 34 XP SP3

E 23 SUS  •Free Network Device Manager  •Real-time Network Traffic Monitor  • Ezines